Skip to main content

Table 3 Unadjusted and adjusted percentage of women who experienced various symptoms of anxiety, symptoms of psychogenic non-epileptic seizures, and of psychotic disorders, by exposure to intimate partner violence, socioeconomic and demographic characteristics of the respondent, partner’s characteristics, and exposure to domestic abuse in the parental household

From: Intimate partner violence and mental health in Bolivia

 

Symptoms of anxiety

Symptoms of psychogenic non-epileptic seizures

Symptoms of psychotic disorders

 

Feelings of fear for no apparent reason

Scares easily

Headaches of great intensity

Convulsions, attacks with tongue biting

Hears voices that others do not hear

 

(1)

(2)

(1)

(2)

(1)

(2)

(1)

(2)

(1)

(2)

Unadjusted

Adjusted

Unadjusted

Adjusted

Unadjusted

Adjusted

Unadjusted

Adjusted

Unadjusted

Adjusted

Percentage

Percentage

Percentage

Percentage

Percentage

Percentage

Percentage

Percentage

Percentage

Percentage

 

(CI)

(CI)

(CI)

(CI)

(CI)

(CI)

(CI)

(CI)

(CI)

(CI)

Intimate partner violence

          

  No abuse (reference)

45.6

46.0

62.8

63.3

51.0

50.8

6.5

6.4

11.2

11.5

(43.9-47.3)

(44.3-47.7)

(61.1-64.6)

(61.6-65.0)

(49.3-52.7)

(49.1-52.4)

(5.7-7.4)

(5.6-7.2)

(10.1-12.3)

(10.4-12.7)

  Psychol. abuse only

49.0*

49.7*

67.0**

67.0*

58.5***

58.9**

8.3*

8.6**

13.9*

13.5

(46.4-51.6)

(50.8-56.2)

(64.7-69.4)

(64.6-69.4)

(55.9-61.1)

(56.4-61.5)

(6.7-9.8)

(7.0-10.2)

(12.0-15.7)

(11.7-15.3)

  Physical abuse (no sexual)

54.9***

53.5***

67.6**

66.6

58.0***

58.3***

9.3**

9.4***

15.7***

15.3**

(52.1-57.7)

(50.8-56.2)

(64.9-70.3)

(63.9-69.4)

(55.3-60.7)

(55.6-60.9)

(7.7-10.8)

(7.9-11.0)

(13.4-17.9)

(13.0-17.5)

  Sexual abuse¥

61.2***

59.3***

72.8***

71.8***

66.9***

65.5***

13.1***

12.4***

25.2***

24.0***

(56.9-65.5)

(55.1-63.7)

(68.5-77.1)

(67.6-76.0)

(62.4-71.4)

(61.1-69.9)

(9.9-16.4)

(9.2-15.6)

(21.0-29.3)

(20.1-27.9)

Respondent experienced physical abuse in childhood

          

  No (reference)

 

47.2

 

64.0

 

52.1

 

7.0

 

12.2

 

(44.9-50.9)

 

(61.8-66.1)

 

(49.9-54.4)

 

(5.7-8.3)

 

(10.6-13.8)

  Yes

 

49.9

 

65.9

 

56.1**

 

8.2

 

14.1

 

(48.4-51.4)

 

(64.4-67.3)

 

(54.7-57.5)

 

(7.4-9.0)

 

(13.0-15.2)

Respondent experienced psychological abuse in childhood

          

  No (reference)

 

49.3

 

64.8

 

55.3

 

8.0

 

14.0

 

(47.7-50.9)

 

(63.2-66.4)

 

(53.7-56.9)

 

(7.1-8.9)

 

(12.8-15.2)

  Yes

 

49.0

 

66.0

 

54.5

 

7.7

 

13.0

 

(47.1-50.9)

 

(64.2-67.8)

 

(52.6-56.3)

 

(6.7-8.7)

 

(11.7-14.3)

Respondent reports father beat her mother

          

  No (reference)

 

48.4

 

64.3

 

54.2

 

7.0

 

12.7

 

(46.6-50.2)

 

(62.6-66.0)

 

(52.3-56.0)

 

(6.1-8.0)

 

(11.3-14.1)

  Yes/Don’t know

 

49.8

 

66.2

 

55.6

 

8.5*

 

14.3

 

(48.0-51.2)

 

(64.6-67.8)

 

(53.9-57.4)

 

(7.5-9.5)

 

(13.1-15.4)

Region

          

  La Paz (reference)

 

53.3

 

69.9

 

54.3

 

6.9

 

13.5

 

(50.5-56.1)

 

(67.6-72.3)

 

(51.9-56.8)

 

(5.6-8.1)

 

(11.4-15.5)

  Chuquisaca

 

43.0**

 

60.7***

 

54.5

 

5.2

 

6.7***

 

(37.9-48.2)

 

(56.4-65.0)

 

(48.0-61.0)

 

(3.7-6.8)

 

(4.7-8.7)

  Cochabamba

 

50.8

 

66.4*

 

61.0**

 

11.3***

 

15.2

 

(48.1-53.6)

 

(63.3-69.5)

 

(58.0-64.0)

 

(9.0-13.7)

 

(13.3-17.2)

  Oruro

 

49.0

 

63.3**

 

50.1

 

6.5

 

6.8***

 

(44.5-53.4)

 

(59.5-67.2)

 

(44.6-55.6)

 

(4.7-8.3)

 

(4.8-8.8)

  Potosí

 

46.1

 

58.6***

 

45.8***

 

7.7

 

10.7

 

(41.5-50.6)

 

(54.6-62.5)

 

(42.2-49.3)

 

(5.5-9.7)

 

(8.2-13.2)

  Tarija

 

51.9

 

68.5

 

58.3

 

7.6

 

17.5*

 

(48.6-55.2)

 

(64.6-72.4)

 

(55.2-61.4)

 

(5.5-9.7)

 

(14.5-20.5)

  Santa Cruz

 

45.6***

 

64.8**

 

55.0

 

6.7

 

16.1

 

(43.0-48.1)

 

(61.8-67.7)

 

(52.1-57.9)

 

(5.4-8.0)

 

(13.8-18.4)

  Beni

 

46.3*

 

51.3***

 

58.6

 

11.6**

 

12.2

 

(41.0-51.7)

 

(45.9-56.6)

 

(54.2-63.0)

 

(8.3-14.8)

 

(9.4-14.9)

  Pando

 

44.3**

 

61.3**

 

59.6

 

12.9***

 

21.1**

 

(39.6-49.0)

 

(56.5-66.1)

 

(54.4-64.6)

 

(9.4-16.3)

 

(16.6-25.7)

Residence

          

  Urban (reference)

 

48.5

 

64.9

 

53.1

 

6.9

 

13.7

 

(46.5-50.5)

 

(62.8-66.9)

 

(50.7-55.4)

 

(5.8-8.0)

 

(12.2-15.2)

  Rural

 

50.1

 

66.0

 

58.0

 

9.0

 

13.4

 

(47.2-53.1)

 

(63.4-68.6)

 

(54.7-61.2)

 

(7.5-10.6)

 

(11.4-15.4)

Education

          

  None (reference)

 

53.1

 

69.4

 

61.1

 

7.5

 

11.3

 

(47.6-58.6)

 

(64.4-74.4)

 

(55.4-66.7)

 

(5.1-9.9)

 

(7.7-14.9)

  Primary

 

51.0

 

67.5

 

58.9

 

8.2

 

14.7

 

(49.0-53.0)

 

(65.5-66.7)

 

(56.7-61.1)

 

(7.2-9.3)

 

(13.2-16.3)

  Secondary

 

48.6

 

64.2

 

51.3**

 

7.5

 

13.1

 

(46.0-51.2)

 

(61.7-66.7)

 

(48.6-54.0)

 

(6.0-9.0)

 

(11.2-14.9)

  Higher

 

41.3**

 

58.2**

 

45.3***

 

6.8

 

10.9

 

(36.3-46.4)

 

(53.5-62.9)

 

(40.4-50.3)

 

(4.3-9.4)

 

(7.5-14.3)

SES

          

  First (reference)

 

50.1

 

66.6

 

57.9

 

9.1

 

11.5

 

(46.3-53.9)

 

(62.8-70.4)

 

(53.9-61.9)

 

(7.0-11.1)

 

(9.1-14.0)

  Second

 

49.2

 

66.9

 

52.4**

 

7.7

 

14.4*

 

(45.9-52.4)

 

(63.8-70.1)

 

(48.2-56.7)

 

(6.2-9.3)

 

(12.1-16.8)

  Third

 

51.4

 

67.2

 

55.3

 

7.9

 

15.1

 

(48.7-54.1)

 

(64.6-69.8)

 

(52.6-58.0)

 

(6.3-9.6)

 

(12.9-17.2)

  Fourth

 

49.1

 

65.3

 

55.2

 

6.5

 

14.3

 

(46.2-52.0)

 

(62.5-68.0)

 

(52.1-58.4)

 

(4.9-8.2)

 

(12.3-16.3)

  Fifth

 

45.8

 

60.8

 

54.0

 

7.8

 

12.0

 

(42.2-49.5)

 

(57.6-64.0)

 

(50.1-57.9)

 

(5.7-9.9)

 

(9.5-14.5)

Work status

          

  Not working (reference)

 

47.8

 

65.5

 

55.4

 

7.0

 

12.4

 

(45.7-49.9)

 

(63.4-67.6)

 

(53.3-57.4)

 

(6.0-8.1)

 

(11.0-13.8)

  Working

 

49.8

 

65.2

 

54.7

 

8.3

 

14.2*

 

(48.3-51.4)

 

(63.7-66.7)

 

(53.3-56.2)

 

(7.4-9.2)

 

(13.1-15.3)

Age

          

  15-24 (reference)

 

49.4

 

66.2

 

47.3

 

5.8

 

13.2

 

(44.9-53.8)

 

(61.8-70.6)

 

(43.1-51.5)

 

(6.8-8.5)

 

(10.3-16.0)

  25-34

 

50.1

 

65.5

 

54.8**

 

7.2

 

14.2

 

(47.7-52.4)

 

(63.3-67.7)

 

(52.5-57.2)

 

(6.1-8.3)

 

(12.6-15.7)

  35-44

 

47.1

 

64.5

 

57.4**

 

8.6

 

13.0

 

(44.4-49.8)

 

(62.0-67.1)

 

(54.7-60.1)

 

(7.1-10.1)

 

(11.1-14.9)

  45-49

 

51.5

 

65.4

 

59.8**

 

11.3*

 

13.9

 

(46.8-56.2)

 

(61.2-69.7)

 

(55.1-64.4)

 

(8.2-14.5)

 

(10.4-17.3)

Marital status

          

  Married (reference)

 

49.6

 

65.3

 

54.6

 

7.7

 

13.3

 

(48.0-51.3)

 

(63.5-67.1)

 

(43.0-56.2)

 

(6.8-8.5)

 

(12.2-14.5)

  Cohabiting

 

48.4

 

65.3

 

54.7

 

8.1

 

13.9

 

(46.3-50.4)

 

(63.1-67.5)

 

(54.5-57.5)

 

(6.9-9.4)

 

(12.4-15.4)

Partner’s age

          

  14-24 (reference)

 

50.5

 

67.2

 

54.8

 

9.7

 

18.8

 

(44.9-56.2)

 

(62.0-72.4)

 

(49.6-60.0)

 

(6.2-13.3)

 

(13.8-23.9)

  25-34

 

49.5

 

65.3

 

53.0

 

8.2

 

13.7*

 

(46.8-52.2)

 

(62.9-67.8)

 

(50.2-55.8)

 

(6.5-9.9)

 

(11.8-15.6)

  35-44

 

47.4

 

64.2

 

55.5

 

8.0

 

12.5*

 

(47.1-52.0)

 

(62.0-66.4)

 

(53.3-57.7)

 

(6.9-9.1)

 

(10.9-14.0)

  45+

 

47.4

 

66.1

 

57.3

 

6.8

 

12.7

 

(43.4-51.5)

 

(62.2-69.9)

 

(53.4-61.2)

 

(5.1-8.5)

 

(10.1-15.3)

Partner’s age, relative to respondent

          

  Same age or younger (ref.)

 

50.3

 

65.9

 

57.2

 

6.8

 

14.3

 

(47.7-52.9)

 

(63.4-68.4)

 

(54.8-59.6)

 

(5.6-8.0)

 

(12.6-16.0)

  1-5 years older

 

49.5

 

65.9

 

53.7*

 

7.7

 

12.8

 

(47.6-51.4)

 

(64.0-67.7)

 

(51.9-55.4)

 

(6.7-8.7)

 

(11.6-14.0)

  6+ years older

 

47.4

 

63.7

 

54.6

 

9.4*

 

14.0

 

(44.7-50.1)

 

(61.2-66.3)

 

(51.7-57.5)

 

(7.7-11.0)

 

(12.1-16.0)

Partner’s education

          

  None (reference)

 

47.9

 

63.7

 

53.2

 

7.0

 

16.9

 

(38.8-57.0)

 

(54.7-72.7)

 

(43.9-62.4)

 

(1.8-12.2)

 

(8.3-25.6)

  Primary

 

50.1

 

65.7

 

55.4

 

8.7

 

14.7

 

(47.6-52.7)

 

(63.5-67.8)

 

(53.0-57.8)

 

(7.4-10.0)

 

(13.0-16.4)

  Secondary

 

50.7

 

66.5

 

55.1

 

7.0

 

12.7

 

(48.5-52.8)

 

(64.3-68.8)

 

(53.0-57.1)

 

(6.0-8.1)

 

(11.1-14.3)

  Higher

 

43.8

 

62.3

 

53.8

 

7.0

 

12.3

 

(39.5-48.1)

 

(58.6-66.1)

 

(49.7-58.0)

 

(5.0-9.1)

 

(9.4-15.1)

Partner’s education compared to respondent

          

  Wife is more educated (reference)

 

47.9

 

63.6

 

55.2

 

7.5

 

12.2

 

(44.9-50.9)

 

(60.9-66.4)

 

(52.4-58.0)

 

(5.9-9.0)

 

(10.3-14.1)

  Same level of education

 

46.9

 

63.5

 

54.6

 

6.7

 

13.8

 

(44.4-49.4)

 

(61.0-65.9)

 

(52.1-57.0)

 

(5.4-8.0)

 

(12.0-15.5)

  Husband is more educated

 

50.6

 

66.8

 

55.0

 

8.4

 

14.1

  

(48.7-52.6)

 

(65.0-68.6)

 

(53.1-56.9)

 

(7.3-9.5)

 

(12.7-15.4)

  1. *p < 0.05 **p < 0.01 ***p < 0.001.
  2. Ψ Respondents who experienced sexual abuse may also have experienced psychological and/or physical abuse.