Table 1 Characteristics of the included studies (China, 2010–2023)
Author | Publication time | Screening model | Screening time | Participants | Residence | Province | Screening age | Screening process | The quality score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Yang, S [14] | 2023 | Opportunistic | 2020.1–2021.12 | 3,874 | Urban | Heilongjiang | 20–70 | BUS followed by MAM | 7 |
Wu, SQ [15] | 2023 | Population | 2013–2021 | 23,009 | Urban | Hebei | 40–74 | BUS in parallel with MAM | 9 |
Wu, L [16] | 2023 | Population | 2021 | 2,231,092 | Urban/ Rural | Guangdong | 35–64 | BUS followed by MAM | 8 |
Han, T [17] | 2023 | Population | 2021.8–2022.3 | 5,974 | Rural | Shanxi | 35–64 | BUS followed by MAM | 8 |
Wu, JM [18] | 2022 | Population | 2018 | 1,156,287 | Rural | Hebei, Henan, Hubei, Guangxi, Xinjiang, Gansu | 35–64 | BUS followed by MAM | 9 |
Zhou, TH [19] | 2021 | Population | 2014–2018 | 11,752 | Urban | Xinjiang | 40–74 | BUS in parallel with MAM | 8 |
Xiao, BL [20] | 2021 | Population | 2017.1–2019.12 | 143,383 | Rural | Guangdong | 26–68 | BUS followed by MAM | 9 |
Shen, SJ [21] | 2021 | Opportunistic/ Population | 2014.1–2016.12 | 20,080 | Urban | Hebei and other 10 provinces | 35–75 | CBE followed by BUS or MAM /BUS followed by MAM | 7 |
Shang, GXH [22] | 2021 | Population | 2017–2020 | 121,916 | Rural | Fujian | 35–64 | BUS followed by MAM | 9 |
Ma, L [23] | 2021 | Population | 2015 | 1,501,753 | Rural | National | 35–64 | BUS followed by MAM | 9 |
Lin, HZ [24] | 2021 | Opportunistic/ Population | 2014 | 48,688 | Rural | Guangdong | 35–64 | CBE followed by BUS or MAM /BUS followed by MAM | 8 |
Zhao, YX [25] | 2020 | Population | 2014 | 1,373,524 | Rural | National | 35–64 | BUS followed by MAM | 9 |
Yang, YP [26] | 2020 | Population | 2013–2018 | 28,621 | Urban | Guangdong | 22–89 | BUS in parallel with MAM | 8 |
Yang, L [27] | 2020 | Population | 2014–2019 | 8,353 | Urban | Beijing | 40–69 | BUS in parallel with MAM | 8 |
Wang, R [28] | 2020 | Population | 2018.12–2019.5 | 27,406 | Urban | Xinjiang | 35–64 | BUS followed by MAM | 8 |
Liu, GM [29] | 2020 | Population | 2013–2019 | 144,151 | Rural | Beijing | 35–64 | BUS followed by MAM | 9 |
Xiong, LL [30] | 2020 | Population | 2016–2018 | 3,151,679 | Rural | Hunan | 35–64 | BUS followed by MAM | 9 |
Huang, XX [31] | 2020 | Population | 2015–2018 | 438,893 | Rural | Fujian | 35–64 | BUS followed by MAM | 9 |
Ding, ST [32] | 2020 | Population | 2013.6–2016.12 | 24,693 | Urban | Beijing | 35–64 | BUS followed by MAM | 8 |
Wu, MQ [33] | 2018 | Population | 2014.12–2015.5 | 5,066 | Urban | Xinjiang | 30–60 | BUS followed by MAM | 8 |
Shen, SY [34] | 2017 | Opportunistic/ Population | 2015.1–12 | 2,062 | Urban | Guangdong | 35–88 | BUS in parallel with MAM | 7 |
Huang, YB [35] | 2016 | Population | 2008.3–2011.12 | 1,226,714 | Urban/ Rural | National | 35–59 | CBE followed by BUS or MAM | 9 |
Shen, S [36] | 2015 | Population | 2008.11–2010.11 | 12,519 | Rural | Hebei and other 7 provinces | 30–65 | MAM/ BUS followed by MAM/ BUS in parallel with MAM | 8 |
Mo, M [37] | 2015 | Opportunistic | 2008.5–2010.10 | 104,809 | Urban | Shanghai | 35–74 | BUS/MAM/BUS followed by MAM | 9 |
Ma, HM [38] | 2015 | Population | 2008–2011 | 64,864 | Urban/ Rural | Shandong | 35–64 | BUS followed by MAM/ BUS in parallel with MAM | 8 |
Yu, HY [39] | 2013 | Population | 2006–2011 | 10,767 | Urban | Guangdong | 30–78 | BUS followed by MAM | 8 |
Xu, J [40] | 2013 | Population | 2010.1–2011.12 | 284,168 | Rural | Guangdong | 35–59 | BUS followed by MAM | 9 |
Shi, SD [41] | 2013 | Population | 2009–2011 | 6,122 | Rural | Shanxi | 30–59 | CBE followed by BUS or MAM | 8 |
Mo, M [42] | 2013 | Population | 2008.5–2012.9 | 14,464 | Urban | Shanghai | 35–74 | BUS in parallel with MAM | 9 |
Gong, YH [43] | 2013 | Population | 2008–2011.12 | 70,292 | Urban | Jiangsu | 18–92 | CBE followed by BUS or MAM | 9 |
Yang, ZH [44] | 2012 | Population | 2008.7–2009.9 | 22,960 | Urban | Liaoning, Tianjin, Jiangxi Shandong | 45–65 | BUS in parallel with MAM | 8 |
Kuang, XM [45] | 2012 | Opportunistic | 2011 | 5,722 | Urban | Guangdong | 17–69 | CBE followed by BUS or MAM | 7 |
Huang, Y [46] | 2012 | Opportunistic/ Population | 2009.3–2011.7 | 3,028 | Urban | Chengdu | 25- | BUS in parallel with MAM | 7 |
Han, LL [47] | 2011 | Population | 2008–2009 | 568,000 | Rural | Beijing | 40–60 | BUS followed by MAM | 9 |
Xu, GW [48] | 2010 | Opportunistic/ Population | 2005–2006 | 118,273 | Urban | Hebei and other 15 provinces | 35–70 | BUS in parallel with MAM | 7 |