From: A systematic review of the childbearing needs of single-child couples
ID | Study/year | Country | Design of the study | Sample/ Sample size | Age of participants | Perceived need for childbearing | Type Of Need |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | D’Albis 2017 [4] | 26 European countries | cross-sectional wave of the EU-SILC( European Union Statistics on Income and Living Conditions (EU-SILC) | Women: 22,143 | 38-44 y | Need for childcare services Increase in women's wages | Supportive: Women's Socio-Occupational support. Financial |
2 | Rutigliano R, Lozano M 2022 [14] | Spain | Cross-sectional | Women: 14556 Men: 2619 | 18-55 y | Grandparent support and informal care | Supportive: Family support |
3 | Luksik I, Bianchi G. 2016 [15] | Slovakia | Correlational | Women: 1,414 | 24-36 y | Need to use the TPB (theory of planned behavior) model to create the intention to have a second child | Educational |
4 | Xu X, Zuo H, Shi Z, et al 2017 [16] | China | Cross sectional | Pregnant women: 2345 | >18 y | Teaching the benefits of children or love for children Increase income Solving the problem of unemployment | Educational Financial |
5 | Jingyue Zhang. 2020 [17] | China | Correlational | Women: 1,834 | 20-45 y | Direct parenting costs and second child anxiety Job concern Paying attention to the availability of entertainment time and place on the anxiety of having a second child in women | Financial Supportive: Socio-Occupational support |
6 | Breton D, Prioux F. 2009 [18] | France | Two complementary household surveys | Men and women: 109,602 | 20-45 y | Balance between work and family for women Culture building for the next generation Participation in religious meetings | Educational Cultural |
7 | Nagase N, Brinton M. 2017 [19] | Japan | Japanese longitudinal survey | Men and women: 20,486 | 20-34 y | Increasing the participation of men in housework and the need for changes in the labor law | Supportive Men's Socio-Occupational support |
8 | Wang q, sun x. 2020 [20] | China | Online survey, Correlational | Men and women: 984 | 18-40 y | Good economic situation Lowering the age of marriage and first childbearing Reducing the spacing between children "Cultural factors" | Financial Cultural |
9 | Mansour F 2018 [21] | United States | Correlational | Women: 14,307 | 21-35 y | The need to solve economic insecurity | Financial |
10 | Levin V, Besedina E. 2016 [22] | Russia | Correlational | Women: 3,292 | 15- 44 y | Having a stable job Availability, affordability and quality of formal childcare Teaching ways to empower the combination of work and family Housing provision Improving the quality of marital relationships | Financial Supportive Socio-Occupational support Educational |
11 | Hwang W, Kim S. 2021 [23] | South Korea | Correlational | Women: 488 | 18-44 y | Culturalization of men's participation in child care. Creating egalitarian gender attitudes Learning appropriate parenting knowledge for fathers at the birth of their first child. | Educational |
12 | Liu J, Liu M, Zhang S. 2020 [24] | China | Cross-sectional | Women: 11, 991 | 18-49 y | Removing economic, parenting (educational and educational) and health barriers to fertility | Financial Educational Supportive: Social health care support |
13 | Zhu C, Yan L 2022 [25] | China | Cross-sectional | Couples: 1,026 | 20-45 y | Prevention of late pregnancy, Spacing 3 to 6 years from the first child. Child allowance and Children's educational barriers | Financial Educational |
14 | Validova A 2018 [26] | Russia | Correlational | Women:35,402 | 15-49 y | Access to formal childcare options | Supportive Socio-Occupational support |
15 | Yoon SY. 2017 [27] | Korea | Correlational | Women: 526 | <41 years | Supporting husbands, parents or husband's family to do housework and child care | Supportive Family support by husbands |
16 | Mobasheri M, Alidousti M. 2013 [7] | Iran | Cross-sectional | Women: 180 | 18-44 y | Reducing costs and economic pressures Government support and facilities for having children Creating the right attitude to childbearing | Financial Educational |
17 | Basu AM, Desai S. 2016 [6] | India | The India human development survey of 2004–2005 (IHDS). Correlational | women: 33,524 | 15-49 y | Counseling for self-actualization and personal freedoms of parents | Educational |